A US court endorses part of the reasoning for the US government’s ban on Anthropic, allowing it to remain in effect for the time being.
A court in Washington D.C. has followed the government’s reasoning regarding the ‘supply chain risk’ label imposed on Anthropic. The company received the label and the associated ban on working with government agencies after Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth was angered by not getting his way. Hegseth refused to accept restrictions on the use of Claude, including those concerning mass surveillance and AI-driven lethal weapons.
Earlier, a court in San Francisco ruled the opposite. This is partly because the reasoning for the ban and the label is based on two pieces of regulation. The first lawsuit concerned one part of the justification; this ruling pertains to the second pillar.
Trump judges
The D.C. court thus determined that the ban on Claude under the 2028 FASCA legislation is justified. Notably, the ruling was reached by a two-to-one majority, with two judges appointed by President Trump following the Trump administration’s reasoning. The third judge, appointed by President H.W. Bush, did not support the ruling on the legitimacy of the ban.
Anthropic can still appeal further, both at the same court and at the Supreme Court, according to CNBC. The latter court is now also ideologically dominated by supporters of the president. In any case, it seems doubtful that Anthropic will lose the ‘supply chain risk’ label anytime soon.
This remains striking, as the ban was never actually intended to punish American companies when they disagree with the government. Early in the discussion between Anthropic and Secretary Hegseth, it became clear that the ban was more of a personal vendetta than a measure to prevent a genuine security problem.
