KBC must repay a school group in Wilrijk 44,300 euros following a phishing incident where a fraudster posing as KBC scammed the treasurer.
The Antwerp Court of Appeal has ruled that KBC must repay 44,300 euros to a school group in Wilrijk following a phishing incident. The court decided that the bank must bear the full loss. In doing so, the court overturns a judgment by the enterprise court from April 7, 2025, in which the school was still required to repay the amount to the bank itself.
Fake call
The incident dates back to February 26, 2022. The fraudster called the treasurer of a school group in Wilrijk, who had power of attorney over the school’s account, claiming to be from KBC. According to the man on the phone, fraud had been committed on her account. He had her provide her card reader details, after which 18 payments totaling 44,300 euros disappeared from the school account. The fraudster gained access to the school account via the treasurer’s personal card, without her having to log in as a proxy holder.
18 payments
In 2023, the school took the treasurer and the bank to the enterprise court. After a long legal procedure, the court ruled that the school had to repay the money to the bank. The parties subsequently filed an appeal.
The court now rules that the 18 payments were not authorized. The use of a bank card, card reader, and PIN does not prove that the school consented. The treasurer only saw a black screen while the fraudster prepared the orders. With this, the court aligns itself with the case law of the Court of Justice and the Dutch Supreme Council. A correctly completed authentication procedure does not rule out that a payment is unauthorized when a third party makes unlawful misuse of it.
Gross negligence
The court also rejects the claim of gross negligence. According to the court, the treasurer acted to protect her own account, not as a proxy holder for the school. The payments clearly deviated from the school’s normal pattern in terms of timing, amounts, sequence, and beneficiaries. KBC failed to demonstrate that it had built in sufficient fraud detection. The bank must now repay the school 44,300 euros.
