Itdaily - European cloud players lack EU ambition on data sovereignty

European cloud players lack EU ambition on data sovereignty

White cloud symbol surrounded by yellow stars of the EU flag on a blue background.

Europe has everything it needs to make itself strategically autonomous on cloud. The industry association of European cloud providers fears that EU leaders have their hearts in the right place, but underestimate the capabilities available locally.

Under the French presidency, the EU is pushing for digital sovereignty. An important aspect in that discussion is the cloud. It has not escaped the EU’s notice that the market is largely in the hands of U.S. hyperscalers and the main competition comes from China. In terms of market dominance, European players are at a disadvantage.

No Airbus of the cloud

However, the European Cloud Industrial Alliance (EUCLIDIA) notes that politicians misjudge the maturity of the European cloud market. “While it is true that there is no Airbus of the cloud, or a provider that is the equivalent of big tech in terms of size or capitalization, the European cloud ecosystem is perfectly capable of meeting the main needs of the market in terms of price, performance and security,” an opinion echoes. “The ecosystem consists of several hundred companies and is even ahead when it comes to cloud native or virtualized 5G.”

EUCLIDIA believes that European leaders should deliver that message, but notes that a different narrative is gaining the upper hand. Instead of highlighting European innovative companies, the red carpet is being rolled out for non-EU players who repeatedly abuse their position and dominance, it sounds.

Although Europe is rightly committed to its own values and standards, according to the sector organization it seems to want to involve mainly large external players in the conversation about them. Because the European market consists of many smaller companies, politicians would wrongly conclude that the necessary knowledge and technology is not present with us. The opposite is true.

Illusion

By not betting on local strengths, Europe risks promoting partial sovereignty, or worse, an illusion. “It is high time for European decision makers to listen and appreciate technology companies from all over Europe. This is necessary for their sustainable expansion, including outside the EU. Without proactive support and a clear demonstration of trust, it becomes impossible for the European cloud industry to compete on equal terms with international competitors. Digital Europe will become powerless, dependent and a witness to de-industrialization,” the signatories conclude with a warning.

The call was signed by the CEOs of Clever Cloud, XWiki SAS, Alibia, Jamespot, Nextcloud, Scaleway and Rapid.Space. The letter is a clear critique of European cloud policy. Between the lines, we read that the European providers are only happy with the general outline of the ambition for sovereignty, but the interpretation, they say, falls short of what is needed. The Gaia-X project, for example, is a measure of nothing, according to Scaleway. That company pulled out as recently as late last year.