Six cybersecurity experts discuss what European regulation such as NIS2 and the Cyber Resilience Act means for technology in Europe. Whether these rules slow down innovation and sovereignty or actually accelerate them is something they don’t all agree on.
Maarten Bovée, CEO of NTX, sees that Belgian SMEs are increasingly asking questions about the origin of technology. “I always expected that mainly larger companies would find that important, but now I see it even with small companies,” he says. “They ask which technology we use. Is it European, American, or Israeli?”
“Or they simply say: if it’s American, we don’t want it. The question is therefore becoming increasingly common among small companies as well.” Ulrich Seldeslachts, CEO of LSEC, calls that ‘a good thing’. Also at the table are Ron Mukherjee, Cybersecurity Consultant at Eset, Olivier Menil, Strategic Advisor BeLux at Fortinet, Kris Spruyt, Senior Business Consultant at Telenet Business, and Satish Balakrishnan, VP and GM at Red Hat Ansible, to debate the impact of regulation on the technological prowess of European companies.
A complicated issue
According to Mukherjee, the meaning of sovereignty is already a matter for discussion. “There is already such a thing as sovereignty washing. It is very difficult to truly determine that. For example, we are a European company, but we also have an American branch and global operations. How far should it go? It is a complicated issue.”
“Extremely complicated,” Balakrishnan agrees, “because Europe does not have the full software stack.” According to him, companies must ask themselves two questions: “Is your underlying infrastructure auditable, and what happens if your vendor changes the terms or access?”
Red Hat, itself an American company, responds to this with open source. “Our entire source code is available to all our customers. This allows you to check if there is a backdoor in it. You don’t pay for licenses, but for support. In addition, multiple third parties can support you because the software is available. As long as you can validate those fundamental matters with your vendors, I think you’re in good shape in terms of sovereignty,” says Balakrishnan.
That is also what Telenet asks of its vendors, explains Spruyt, who must lead his employer toward compliance. “It is part of the onboarding process: we need to know where the data is located. We ask our vendors where they get their data from, where that data is stored, and how they maintain control over it.”
Ideological discussion
The panel sees that ideological arguments give the sovereignty debate extra weight. “We conducted a survey among European SMEs,” Mukherjee chimes in. “It showed that 75 percent of SMEs realize they could be hit by an attack related to cyber warfare. So there really is an awareness around that.”
“Ultimately, sovereignty is a political and technical problem with two totally different answers,” Olivier Menil observes. “If you dive into the technical details and ask which hardware you use in your data center and where the chipset comes from, the discussion is over quickly. In the upcoming European tenders for AI, two American vendors are already being mentioned. Europe currently does not have the full capacity to be completely sovereign.”
Seldeslachts also sees the debate arising from political reasons. “The whole discussion flared up again because of a president named Donald J. Trump, who suddenly started introducing all kinds of tariffs. European entrepreneurs are rightly as risk-averse as they can and must be. They start thinking: what if my cloud is switched off tomorrow?”
“But it’s not just about the purely political. It also has to do with risk, with costs, and with ecology. Why would you constantly send data to the US? There are several good reasons to keep things local, such as data protection, energy awareness, and supporting the European economy,” he adds.
Sovereignty is a political and technical problem with two totally different answers.
Olivier Menil, Strategic Advisor BeLux at Fortinet
European technology under the radar
According to Menil, the European technology sector is boxing in a different weight class than the American one. “Europe has many startups in cybersecurity. We only have two scale-ups and there is no major player.”
“There are plenty of scale-ups and there are certainly large players too,” Seldeslachts responds. “In Belgium, Aikido Security is a good example. Europe definitely has those capabilities: just think of the encryption mechanism we use daily, AES. That was developed here in Belgium. But it doesn’t have the Red Hats or Microsofts of this world to bring them to market. As a result, European technology still remains a bit too much under the radar.”
“What Europe really wants, and we fully support that, is to ensure that European technology and European innovations are also recognized and used by European companies,” says Seldeslachts. “If you invest everything in Microsoft and Azure, Microsoft will of course remain the largest tomorrow. For that very reason, we have started migrating everything to European clouds. We also see that as an investment in our future.”
To the market
According to Bovée, another problem comes into play there. “There are certainly good European companies. It’s not just about the software stack, but also about how you bring it to market. American companies have an ecosystem of channel partners, distributors, and resellers. They have a large market and a lot of capital. Many European companies want to sell directly, but then have an email only in German or Italian. That’s not how it works. We are never going to be successful if we don’t follow the same strategy as the American companies.”
“For almost everything, there are open source projects you can jump into,” Balakrishnan says, looking at his own shop. “At Red Hat, we have built sovereignty into our platforms. In Europe, companies have traditionally been consumers of open source, not contributors. That mentality must change if organizations want to take control of their future needs.”
Seldeslachts agrees. “Much excellent technology, including for cybersecurity, is open source. The use of different types of open source is part of the concept to achieve sovereignty. That is the path Europe wants to take.”
European companies are never going to be successful if they don’t follow the same strategy as American companies.
Maarten Bovée, CEO NTX
Difficult consensus
Yet the experts miss a uniform vision in Europe, even when it comes to regulation. “Although NIS2 is a European regulation, every member state has its own rules, and those rules can change from one day to the next,” says Seldeslachts. “As in Belgium, where the Center for Cybersecurity Belgium (CCB) rightly tightened the rules for healthcare significantly as a result of the rising threat, and the healthcare sector is designated as an essential sector.”
“That is the biggest mistake made with NIS2, in my opinion,” Menil says. “Instead of one regulation, they told national authorities: transpose it in your own country. So you have differences between France, the Netherlands, Luxembourg, and Belgium. A company that wants to expand in the EU must meet the requirements of all EU member states.”
“A good example is the central reporting portal,” says Mukherjee. “Every country had its own opinion on that, and it was very difficult to reach any agreement within ENISA. Even on specific domains, we find it difficult to reach a consensus in Europe.”
“I actually think it’s good that rules like NIS2 and DORA exist, because they make you think, they make you more mature, and they make our world safer,” Spruyt notes. “For an incident at a national level, a company doesn’t want to have to report at a European level. The Digital Omnibus aims to reduce much of that complexity,” Seldeslachts chimes in. “Be prepared, because for the next ten years, a new law will be added almost every year.”
24 hours vs 6 months
Balakrishnan asks for balance between regulation and innovation, looking through an American lens. “In the US, everything moves much faster; a deal can be closed in 24 hours, while in Europe a tender can take six months. By then, the technology has evolved again. Yet you shouldn’t see regulation only as a brake on innovation, because it can also help form a framework for trust and sovereignty. But if you treat compliance and regulation only as paperwork, you don’t build innovation or speed.”
Kris Spruyt focuses mainly on the positive side. “It makes you think: how resilient am I in terms of cybersecurity, how resilient am I against AI fraud? Regulation forces you to think about what you can do better as a company to become more mature. I support regulation because it encourages companies to become more efficient and competitive. You have to embrace it.”
“The great danger is that within larger organizations you start building a compliance project for every regulation, and that these run side-by-side. That creates overhead and waste,” Mukherjee warns. Spruyt nuances this. “NIS2 and DORA have a lot of overlap. Within the organization, one department follows all European rules.”
“The US actually has many more rules than Europe,” Menil points out. According to him, information sharing is difficult in Belgium and the EU. “You have different agencies reporting to different ministries that are not allowed to talk to each other. That is the case in several countries. At the European level, cooperation is even worse. But at a technical level, technical people usually do share. The challenges are at the ‘iron’ level.”
“As a European vendor, we must cooperate with other vendors. We are strong in intelligence, and partners ask for that. Europe can be strong as an ecosystem,” says Mukherjee.
Be prepared, because for the next ten years, a new law will be added almost every year.
Ulrich Seldeslachts, CEO LSEC
Technology as beer
According to Bovée, the effect of rules depends on what their goal is. “Regulation is okay if it’s intended to protect companies and improve security and maturity. But if you do it to stifle innovation, you’re starting from the wrong focus. There’s a nice story about that.”
Bovée reinforces his point with an anecdote. “In Belgium, we have thousands of different beers that taste different. In Germany, somewhere in the Middle Ages, they said: we are going to regulate beer. Now in Germany, you can drink the same beer from twenty different brewers, and it all tastes the same. That’s what you get when you start regulating innovation at a certain point: everything looks the same, tastes the same, and is average. In the US, you have more competition and more people trying things out.”
Seldeslachts disagrees: “Europe does not regulate innovation. I would even say it’s the other way around: thanks to regulation, you get new types of innovation.”
CRA
According to Seldeslachts, that is what the recently enacted Cyber Resilience Act (CRA) is all about. “It was created to protect the European market against Chinese and American vendors who bring insecure products to market. They must apply basic cybersecurity practices. Does that reduce innovation? Of course not. It actually supports innovation, because companies are now coming up with new ways to secure a device.”
“In the past, any company could bring a product to market that was totally insecure. They knew about exploits and vulnerabilities in a device and could still sell it without any problems,” Seldeslachts continues. “Now it is mandatory to report a reported or exploited vulnerability in a product within 24 hours at the European level. It forces manufacturers to deal with those vulnerabilities.”
“Watch out,” Menil chimes in, “vulnerabilities and their exploitation are not the biggest problem in cybersecurity. Those are configuration problems. You can buy the best ten, twenty, thirty cybersecurity products today, but if you don’t deploy them correctly, you are vulnerable.” “Then you’re done for,” Seldeslachts adds. “That’s why CRA also mandates making documentation for correct use available, without customers having to pay for it.”
The effect of NIS2 and related legislation divides the panel. Some experts fear that rules make European technology slower or more uniform; others believe the same rules provide a push toward safer products and more mature companies. Europe will have to choose whether it wants its technology companies to brew characterful Trappist or bland pilsner.
In the past, companies could bring totally insecure products to market. Now they are obliged to deal with vulnerabilities. Does that reduce innovation? Of course not.
Ulrich Seldeslachts, CEO LSEC
